In an age where we buy most of our stuff with a quick swipe or tap of a credit card, a cash stuffing budgeting system can help us keep our eye on the figurative prize. All you need is a few stacks of envelopes, your expenses in cash, and a penchant for sticking to a plan.

Let’s explore the practice of cash stuffing and whether or not this simple budgeting strategy can help you stay on the right financial course.

What Exactly Is Cash Stuffing?

Cash stuffing is a simple budgeting technique where you divide your money into different envelopes, each designated for specific expenses, like groceries, rent, entertainment, or savings. Otherwise known as the envelope budgeting system, the idea is to set aside a certain amount of cash for each category based on your monthly budget. Once you’ve spent all the cash in an envelope, you can’t spend any more in that category until the next budget cycle. This method helps you stay mindful of your spending and live within your means.

TikTok has made cash stuffing trendy for newer generations, but the practice has been around for well over 100 years. The cash stuffing method goes back to a time when electronic transactions didn’t exist, and cash was the main way to pay. Nowadays, its popularity stems from a way to counter our increasing reliance on digital payments and credit, which can sometimes lead to overspending and losing touch with our financial realities.

How to Start Cash Stuffing

1. Pick Your Budget Categories

The first step in cash stuffing is to figure out the different areas where you spend money. Common categories include rent/mortgage, utilities, groceries, transportation, entertainment, and savings. Each of these will have its own envelope.

2. Set a Budget for Each Category

Based on your income and expenses, decide how much money you need to allocate to each category every month. Be realistic and honest with your spending habits to set achievable budgets.

3. Withdraw the Cash

After you set your budget, withdraw the total amount needed for all your categories in cash. This might mean a monthly or bi-weekly trip to the bank, depending on your pay schedule.

4. Stuff Your Envelopes

Divide the cash among the envelopes according to your budgeted amounts. Each envelope now holds the money you can spend in that expense category for the month.

5. Spend and Track

Use the cash from the respective envelopes for your expenses. Once an envelope is empty, that’s your sign to stop spending in that category until the next refill.

6. Adjust as Necessary

After a month or two, you may find that some categories need more or less money than others. Adjust your allocations accordingly.

Pros and Cons of Cash Stuffing

Pros

• More mindful spending: Swiping a credit card can be a borderline thoughtless action; using cash, meanwhile, makes you more conscious of your spending. You physically see the money leaving the envelope, which can have a psychological impact that’s effective in learning how to stop impulse buying.
  
• Limits overspending: The envelope budget system has a hard limit. Once the cash in an envelope is gone, it’s a clear indicator that you’ve reached your spending limit for that category, thereby preventing overspending.
  
• Simple and tangible: The cash stuffing method is straightforward and tangible. It doesn’t require complex financial knowledge or math, making it doable for almost anyone.
  
• Helps in debt reduction: By limiting spending and avoiding the overuse of credit cards, cash stuffing can be an effective tool in reducing debt.

Cons

• Security risk: Carrying a large amount of cash poses a security risk. If lost or stolen, it cannot be easily recovered—unlike credit card funds.
  
• Inconvenient: Digital transactions are the norm, and relying on cash can be inconvenient—especially when visiting businesses that don’t accept cash at all. It also requires regular trips to the bank and can be ineffective for making online purchases.
  
• Lacks flexibility: The rigid nature of cash budgeting doesn’t accommodate unexpected expenses well. In emergencies, you may find yourself shuffling money between envelopes or withdrawing more cash. Aim to build an emergency fund with at least three months’ worth of expenses outside of your envelope system to cover any unexpected or urgent costs.
  
• No digital tracking: Unlike digital budgeting tools, cash stuffing doesn’t provide an automatic record of your transactions, making it harder to track your spending over time.

Does Cash Stuffing Work?

The best budgeting method is the one you’ll stick to, so cash budgeting can certainly work if it aligns with your particular habits and goals.  If you’re motivated to reduce your spending and track every dollar, cash stuffing can be an effective tool to achieve those goals. However, it may not be the best fit for folks with a penchant for digital tracking and budgeting.

Author